Page 307 - Georgius Raguseus: Peripateticae disputationes
Basic HTML Version
N
F etex S impiiH
d
oXtnditui tf»bf}sintum perfefenjsbitem non tfft
,
fsiu iqu: Antoris in:}*
flantt* nesaittr.
C a p .
XXXVit*
On potefr autem Nouus Autor huiufccmodi refponflombus acquivfccre, ncc vitacr,
ratione adduci,v: arfirmcr»fubfrantiam non per Ic quidem,fcd per accidc ns folum ici
.
fib:l?n; effciidcocx Simpliciuofredcrc nititur,quonam patfoea propofitio inrclligcnriiir,
StmpUdiu. cIua fubftantia per accidcns Jcnfibilisdiccbarur. Rtcnim Simplicius m coinm.tfj.lib ri i.dc
Anima,haede re loqucrusdocuit,fubftantiam non co modo,quocommunia accidentia, (rn
fibilcmcftrrnanquc communia accidentia ideo fnifibilia funt,quia fenfum cxcitant:fuhflan
tia.veroideo fcnfibilwdicitur,quiadum.ilia cum fcnftbibcxiftir;ratioexcitarur adcognirio
Noi« Aut nrn' ° r^ » u am dc ipfa. Kx quibus verbis dicit Nouus Autor, prxd:clam propofitionnn
et Simplicio r.cr. dc omni fubftincia/itl de ca foliam,qu* accidcmibus fubiaccr.cuiufmodi eft 'ubftarta
tiic;t,iiibi*jn coni'pofiu,intclligcndam cffc.hxc cmmeft,qux per accidcs fenfibiiis dicitur. Njncaut noi
fiNin
ic- non ioquimur,air tpfc.dc fubftantia copofitaJcd dc difTeret:a fubften:ialt, qux vt nullibi d -
eidem fenfi- <ihimcft;ita uuJubi dici potcft.qum fcnfu percipiatur. Tamctfi aucontas Simpl;c:j hac n
ve* rc va-^ ‘ fufpedh fit,quippecui,vnacum exteris Gncis,faJfa liare, quam modo rci;cu:iui,
r* drum ico dc formis elementorum fententia communirer tribuatur, ramen ex codcmmec Simplicio o*
fccndcre libe:,fubftantiam per fe,&quatenus fubftantia cft,fcn!ib:lem non cfle.quod idem
simpli;ij»u- erit,ac fiprobaucrifr.usr.ullam fubftantiam perfc fenlibilcmefic. Attulit tantum Nouus
l° r ? ' />JC' Autorquxdam Simplicij v«bn,vt firqueter facere foie;,qu6facuius jd,quod in animoh»
xe u pc. a. [>ct>ifu-^cjc p0j]if. £go vero integram,& dilucidiorem quidem, cx iam erraro commetario,
Simplicij explanationem afferamtaliorum pofteaiudiciumerir,qu:dnamcx illius vcrksc-
AutotitJi si
P °^ r,Ait ergo Simplicius,auemadmodum homo cft dominus pci acddens.au: frar jas
piicii ,<ju«o efficit pcraccidcnsjquia hxcipfa eidem,quatenus homo eft,non conucniunr,ira(& becfuitt
llcrdit if f.ib cjus
vtlbl)S:st>pantiafenfthuefabitclafecundum accident} quoniam non quatenus fubf}.\:u.
t i ‘qjiteniit
bifcc verbis ita contra Nouuro Aurorem argumentor; Differentia fubftantialis, vrc.ili-
fjbHina r:i, citas»fubftant:a r.c,ao accidensefteSi acctdensjnon igitur poteft ciTeforma fubftanrialisili
cuius elementi.S; fubftantiajereo nc fcnfu quidcm,quanuiseftdifTcrrnrij fubftantialis, r:r
irsi n<inci-r» . .
p
r % i
*
^ i n
•
i"
Aff.ni Auto. cipipotcft;quoniamtvt Simpuuusaiuubmmtia.quntcnusfubftamiacft.fcnnbusrinn luolj
c:’ ir:‘ 11 ° ni1^ fubftantia,quxcGque illa Jit.iiuefimplcx,flue compotita,fenfibus fubijcipn
J't
per/e tcft: Prxtefcaoftci,do,hanc Nou: AntorisrcfponhouemapcrtiiTimutnefTccffugiumiCLa
feiiibikncn doquidetn illam elemeutorum tantum qualitatibus, quas eorum fubftantialcs fo rm a sti
CfiJitnjjiic. defcnd!it,non etiam alijs form«,aurdi
flfttcnrijs
fubliar.tiahbus accommodaro potefr.
Qai-
ram eniin cxco,fubfrjnria!is forma,aut differentia oouis.equi, aut alterius cuiufpum rei,
fttnccalida,an frigida,alba,an nigra,dura,an moliis,afpcia,an lenis,grau is,an IcuisfSi enim
pci fc fenfibiiis eft,opus clt fanc,vr aitquo fcnfu percipiatur,atqiadeo vr fenfus cognofcat,
illam vcl co modo,quodximu
5
,vel alio quopiam motio afloStamcflc:fenfus enim nihiJ
liuddignofcereqiicjnr.-ftii falfum eft diccre.botiis.crji, aut alieriu* cuiufpiam rei farmam,
. velditfcrentiam rubfrantialcin.pcrfcaliquomcKloafiedlam effe:ergo falfum cft dicere, .ili-
i<!emjpcrtif cuius rei formam,aurdi/Tercn:iam fubAantialcm pci fe fcnniiilem cfse. Quod vt \"oi:us Ali
fima Simpli- to: facilius intclljjjat.ipfius cnam Simplici^ aucorttace firmabojqui in prxdicaincntis ,c.dc
lobomun*4 q u a lita te ,in cxp o iitio r.c t e r t i* /p ec ic t,ap c iT iffii7 icn eg au ir, iitb ita n tta le s d ifferen tias per fc
Icnftbllcs cfsciita cnini icribitt^«/«J
rei mAxtmuin indutum eft, qui* fptetes futtHamurum
non (emunguntur fenfutmcyut tHutn atttngnn/t(?r miuentiyu&ndvquidcm fenfus non fttfnb
f i ansurum ptr(tpti«ut:n*m ibfus v ix trttetielfus recipis,fedfenfus esi rectpstuus qu*
I
i
/
a i
S ,
qu
.<
'affeitti>us,fr raistmbut funt^quAS qutiiates etiam corpus n/ttum
tft
rtctfere.fc
hjt ',y<±
Utates menentfenfum .
Potuit
nc Simplicius rem hanc apettius cdoecie, oficr.dcrcque
nulli
fabltantiam fcnfu attingi poffc, cum,cam vix :ntcllc6u pcrcipi,aiseruerit ^ Arumaducitit
.
.
Noi:us Autor hunc Sm-plicij locum ,
5
c propterea aliam effinxit folutionem
,
quam
wn/ttfpoti ex eodemettamSimplidoaliCTJt acccpifie. Dicendum itaque putat, pro folutionc xa-
fio »diuode rionis La tinorum,calidiratcm i^nis fcniuquidcm n6 percipi,vt fubfranria clr, prout icilicct
Liti- pfi jn
ci5C,CLimuJi
nexu aliaru qua liratu: fcd tantummodo cabdiratc.n
rw-n.
" pcrcipi fcnfu,quatcnus fui genetis qualitas cfL -Micmda h icccn ie ft huius v;mnconftan-
•
tia,
j
o
2
Dc
Formis Elementorum ,
